Every check, its legal basis, and what could not be verified
21 checks run against your answers. Each row below names the provision it rests on and how far that provision was confirmed against a public source. None of it is legal advice, and a citation that is wrong is a bug worth reporting.
The article number and the obligation it describes were both read in an official text or an equivalent primary source. A finding at this level can be argued with the citation attached.
The obligation is established but a detail is not, for example a national language clause or a penalty ceiling. Findings at this level say which part is missing instead of presenting a guess as a rule.
Regulation (EU) 2023/988 — GPSR
Applies from 13 December 2024 (Art. 52). Article 16 decides who answers for the product, Article 19 adds the information a distance seller has to show, Article 44 is the penalty article and carries no amount and no turnover percentage.
| Check | What is tested | Provision | Confirmation |
|---|---|---|---|
| GPSR-RP-001 | A seller established outside the EU has named no economic operator established inside it | Art. 16(1) with Reg (EU) 2019/1020 Art. 4 | Verified source |
| GPSR-RP-002 | The responsible person is not identified on the product, its packaging or an accompanying document | Art. 16(3) | Verified source |
| GPSR-RP-003 | The offer page does not display the responsible person | Art. 19(b) | Verified source |
| GPSR-RP-004 | The offer page does not identify the manufacturer | Art. 19(a) | Verified source |
| GPSR-RP-005 | The offer page carries no product identification such as pictures, type, batch or serial number | Art. 19(c) | Partly verified source |
| GPSR-LANG-001 | Instructions and warnings are not covered in a language the destination market requires | Art. 9(7) and Art. 19(d) | Partly verified source |
| GPSR-CE-001 | A CE-marked product has no declaration of conformity on file | Toy Safety Directive 2009/48/EC Art. 15-16; LVD 2014/35/EU; EMC 2014/30/EU | Verified source |
| GPSR-CE-002 | A declaration exists but the physical traceability behind it is thin | Directive 2009/48/EC Art. 16; LVD 2014/35/EU; EMC 2014/30/EU | Partly verified source |
| GPSR-COSMETIC-001 | A cosmetic is missing its EU responsible person, product information file or CPNP notification | Regulation (EC) 1223/2009 Art. 4, Art. 11, Art. 13 | Verified source |
Regulation (EU) 2025/40 — PPWR, and national packaging law
The PPWR applies from 12 August 2026 (Art. 71). What bites on that date is substance limits, technical documentation, producer registration under Art. 44(4), the authorised representative under Art. 45(3) and labelling. Empty space (Art. 24), recyclability grading (Art. 6) and recycled content (Art. 7) all start on 1 January 2030, so they are reported as future duties rather than present breaches.
| Check | What is tested | Provision | Confirmation |
|---|---|---|---|
| EPR-DE-LUCID | No German packaging registration (LUCID) is held | VerpackG § 9 and § 13; PPWR Art. 44(4) | Verified source |
| EPR-FR-UIN | No French packaging registration (UIN) is held | AGEC law; ADEME/SYDEREP registration; PPWR Art. 44(4) | Verified source |
| EPR-PKG-001 | One or more destination markets have no packaging producer registration at all | PPWR Art. 44(4); national packaging schemes | Verified source |
| EPR-PANEU-001 | Offers are stored across several countries through a pan-European programme while registrations are missing in the markets that programme covers | Marketplace packaging gate; PPWR Art. 19(2) and Art. 44(4) | Verified source |
| PPWR-001 | The packaging declaration or technical documentation is not in place | PPWR Art. 15 and Annex VII; Art. 71 | Verified source |
| PPWR-002 | Plastic packaging is used, which carries material duties and a recycled-content baseline | PPWR Art. 5 and Art. 6; Art. 7 from 2030 | Partly verified source |
| PPWR-003 | Design duties that start in 2030 are surfaced as future cost, not as a present breach | PPWR Art. 6, Art. 7, Art. 10, Art. 24 (from 2030-01-01) | Verified source |
Directive 2012/19/EU (WEEE) and Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 (batteries)
WEEE is transposed nationally, so the test is what each register actually requires rather than a single EU rule. Battery producer responsibility is the most frequently missed of the three registers because it is usually a separate number from the packaging one.
| Check | What is tested | Provision | Confirmation |
|---|---|---|---|
| EPR-DE-WEEE | No German WEEE registration with stiftung ear is held | ElektroG § 6 and § 45 | Verified source |
| EPR-WEEE-002 | Electrical products are sold into markets with no WEEE registration for those markets | National transposition of Directive 2012/19/EU | Partly verified source |
| EPR-BATT-001 | Products containing batteries ship without a producer registration | BattG (DE); Regulation (EU) 2023/1542 | Partly verified source |
Marketplace gates
These are not statutory duties. They are the conditions a marketplace attaches to staying live, and in practice they suppress offers faster than any authority does.
| Check | What is tested | Provision | Confirmation |
|---|---|---|---|
| PLAT-ATTEST-001 | The marketplace has not accepted product safety information for the offer | GPSR Art. 19(d); marketplace product-safety gate | Verified source |
| PLAT-ATTEST-002 | Safety information was submitted for a product that carries warnings, rather than as warnings | GPSR Art. 19(d); marketplace attestation definition | Partly verified source |
Claims that circulate widely and that this tool does not repeat
Each of these appears in seller forums, agency blogs or both. Where a claim could not be traced to a primary source it is listed here rather than used as a selling argument, and a correction is treated as a fix to the product.
Not in the regulation. Article 44 sets no amount and no turnover percentage; the 4% figure comes from a 2021 proposal that was never adopted. Germany fines under ProdSG § 28: EUR 10,000 in general, EUR 100,000 where corrective action is not taken.
They do not, as far as a public source could be traced here. Only Germany has verified ceilings (VerpackG EUR 200,000 and EUR 100,000, ElektroG § 45 EUR 100,000). France, Italy, Spain, Austria, the Netherlands, Poland and Sweden are reported as not established rather than estimated.
No public source ties the two. Amazon publishes brand-registry revocation grounds in trademark and abuse terms only. The report treats it as unconfirmed brand risk, not as a compliance finding.
One case is verifiable: Germany, through § 6 ProdSG. Austria follows the same practice but no cited clause was traced. France, Italy, Spain, the Netherlands, Poland and Sweden apply a language expectation without a clause this release could quote, so findings there say so instead of asserting a rule.
Sources disagree. VerpackDG § 66(2) makes PPWR infringements punishable from 12 February 2027; another reading applies § 68(17) from 12 August 2026. Inside that window the report flags the disagreement instead of picking a side.
Circulating in seller forums, unsupported. Art. 44(4) PPWR requires registration in the member state where packaging is made available, and German domestic trade is still German territory. The tool keeps requiring it.
Spotted an error in any row above? Write to clint@clintforge.com with the check ID. A build check fails when this page and the engine disagree about which checks exist, so a correction here cannot silently drift out of the report.